(In case anyone is confused by the title, P2V means turning a physical system into a virtual machine, and V2V means converting one type of virtual machine into another — eg. a Xen VM into a VMWare VM. Usually what we are talking about is making the conversion completely or mostly automatic.)
There are some things that Linux distros do which make P2V and V2V conversions harder than they really need to be. In this article I hope to collect a few of these things. If you can think of any more, post them as comments and I’ll incorporate them here.
1. Your disk partitions are on hard-coded device names like /dev/hda1
When we virtualize a disk, we usually want to install alternate (“paravirt”) drivers, but these drivers cause the disk names to change. Xen paravirt drivers use
/dev/xvda and the standard Linux virtio drivers use
Your Linux distro may have scattered references to /dev/hd* and /dev/sd* in /etc/fstab, inside the boot initramfs, and maybe in some scripts which are used to decrypt the hard drive at boot time. virt-v2v has to perform intimate surgery on the disk to find and fix all these.
Luckily there is a easy way to avoid this: every major filesystem and swap type for Linux supports either labels or UUIDs. These are preserved transparently when converting, and distros should use these scrupulously, and never use device names.
Update: LVM partition names are OK too. (Thanks Matt Booth).
2. You didn’t expect the network hardware would change
When the OS gets converted, it is highly likely that the network device will appear to change, but mysteriously it will still have the same MAC address.
That’s not supposed to happen with real hardware — MAC addrs are allocated by IEEE and no two manufacturers should have the same ones. Virtual hardware doesn’t play by the same rules.
What we’d want you to do is to keep track of the MAC addresses of each interface and when you see the same MAC, give it the same ethX device name.
Update: See comments.
3. Your kernel doesn’t support virtual devices
Some Linux distros don’t contain drivers for virtual (virtio) devices. There’s a variety of reasons for this, not all of them solvable: The kernel might predate virtio, or the drivers are closed source (eg. for older VMWare), or they might have been compiled out. In some cases a whole different kernel is required (as was true for earlier versions of Xen).
In any case, installing a new kernel inside the guest and making it bootable is major surgery, and we’d rather not do that.
4. X needs reconfiguration
Pretty much the same as for disks and network devices, the display device will also change after conversion (either to a generic Cirrus Logic 54xx or to one of the new accelerated paravirt devices).
Ideally X would just deal with this and bring up a display on the first device it finds, and it should probe all possible devices, but by no means all distros work this way.
5. Making assumptions about the environment around the machine
Static IP addresses and static DNS resolution are a pain when moving a machine. Although not necessarily the fault of the distro as such, it’s better if machines are configured to pick up their network details from a DHCP server.
6. Don’t assume CPU extensions like SSE3 will always be there
After conversion, the new virtual CPU and motherboard you see won’t look very much like the old ones. CPU extensions like SSE, vectors, NX might come or go. The apparent CPU model and manufacturer might have changed. Therefore if you spent any time optimizing the installed packages, those optimizations are wasted and might even cause programs to crash.
It’s better to make your packages generic and have programs detect the runtime environment and optimizations needed each time they start up. (Actually, it’s worse than this when you also consider live migration, because the processor might change while a program is running — no one has really solved this one satisfactorily yet).
As you can see, P2V and V2V conversions are like major hardware changes. Your distro should be able to handle just about all the hardware changing underneath it. It should probe everything at boot, hard-code nothing, and be designed to cope gracefully with abrupt changes.
Update: A thread on fedora-devel-list about this issue.
4 responses to “What things make P2V/V2V conversion hard?”
I am not sure about relying on the MAC address being the same… You will run into problems if you run the VM on the same network segment as the real hardware. I’m not sure how the hypervisor would deal with running the VM on the original hardware either (VM and host sharing a MAC).
In any case, ideally you’d want a solution that survived p2p as well as p2v (i.e. swapping harddrives between machines).
Maybe the Linux kernel needs a config file to map hardware explicitly: “PCI card ID –> device ###”, “MAC address –> interface ###”, etc…
The first time I reordered my hard-disk boot order in the BIOS I ended up with a huge mess 😉
DDD: Yeah, I agree. Maybe that one wasn’t well thought out. However something does need to be done about the ethernet interface renumbering problem.
udev stores map of interface names and mac addresses to prevent renumbering.
> Update: LVM partition names are OK too.
Yeah, I thought so too until this week, when the current incarnation of kernel+udev+lvm2 in rawhide fell into disagreement on who to create /dev//. It seems safer to stick to labels from now on.